Trinity Methodist Church
This week I’ll dissect this church interior from Trinity Methodist Church in downtown Denver. I took a day to walk around Denver and take pictures of buildings and had planned on visiting some churches along the way. From a pre-planning perspective, sometimes I start with Google maps to get a feel for a particular area. If I find something that I think might be interesting, I’ll do a Google image search or a Flickr search, say Trinity Methodist Church, and take a look at images that other people took. If it seems interesting, I’ll add it to my list for the walk. This saves some time and at least gives me an idea of how many locations I want to check out. Keep in mind that half the fun of these walks is just exploring an area and stumbling across locations along the way.
I’m no expert on photographing churches, but let common sense prevail. These are houses of worship and should be treated with due respect. I always find someone and ask if it is OK if I photograph the church, and I won’t photograph without someone giving me permission. Also, I only go where the normal public would go. If the church is open in the middle of the week, good chance you’ll find an empty church to photograph and you won’t bother someone wanting some peace and quiet.
I took a fair amount of photos of Trinity Methodist since it is a beautiful church. I brought my tripod but opted to not bring it with me. This puts me at a slight disadvantage as I can’t use it for slow shutter speeds, which is typical for dark interiors. The workaround is to increase the ISO setting on my camera in order to photograph at slightly higher shutter speeds so I have a fighting change of not blurring the image. Image stabilization is a wonderful addition to the modern day cameras. Needless to say, I had image stabilization turned on for all these images. With higher ISO settings (like 800+), you will get more noise artifacts, and a lot more noise artifacts in the darker regions of the image, so a good noise reduction program does wonders for cleaning up the noise when you’re doing your post-processing. More on noise reduction when I talk about post processing this image.
For this particular image, I liked the lighting on the pipe organ, that caught my eye. I also liked the lighting on the angel (lower left) and bible stand (lower right). I’m sure these things have proper names, but I’m ignorant of such things, my apologies. These items are placed specifically, both by the church and by me with this zoom selection and where I physically stood. The composition is a triangle. A rather obvious triangle and after post processing, a very obvious triangle. Maybe it’s too obvious, but that’s OK.
I’m thinking black and white all the way with this image. The color version is pretty, but the feel needed to be BW. The overall tone of the image is dark and quiet, as I think it should be. I wanted the pipe organ to pop against the darker background and I wanted the angel and bible stand to be brighter, forming the triangle. Like any BW conversion, there are a million and one different ways to convert the image into something pleasing. You’ll have to work your images in different ways and pick one that is pleasing to you. Separating the tones in the dark background is not difficult but does require some more advanced Photoshop skills. You basically make a selection and then use the curves tool to add or subtract contrast and brightness. Almost always I’m adding contrast, as for brightness, it just depends on the image and what I want to present. By adding contrast, I’m separating the tones. If I don’t do that I’ll end up with a rather dull, flat, looking background. Again, this is a season to taste thing.
This image is slightly toned as well. I added some dark brown to the dark areas of the image and kept the highlights untoned. If you choose, you can add some toning to the highlights as well. Split toning is the term used if you tone the dark areas of an image one particular tint and the highlights a different tint. You can use tools like Nik’s Silver Efex Pro 2 for toning, or Photoshop. I like both, but tend to favor the controls I have using Photoshop. The way I do it is arguably over complicated and probably worth a blog entry by itself. Quickly, it is done by adding a colored layer, changing the blend mode, and then using the Apply Image command to mask the toning effect. I may need to do this a couple times to get the effect that I want to achieve.
Regarding noise reduction. For this image, and most that I work on, it’s a two step process. I’m almost always shooting RAW, that means I make some basic adjustments in Adobe Camera Raw (ACR). One of those adjustments is two-fold, reduce noise, and apply a little sharpening to the image, not too much of either. The brunt of the noise reduction and sharpening will be done later in Photoshop using separate tools. For noise reduction I use Nik’s Define. Noiseware is arguably the best noise reduction production, but, on the Mac, it has a serious flaw, it only works in 32-bit mode and not 64-bit mode (for you PC folks, look closely at the fine print on the Noiseware site to make sure you’re compatible with 64-bit mode), all Nik software is 64-bit compatible - thank you Nik.
Vignetting. I once read that a good vignette mask isn’t seen. I like that statement. Either make it that way or hit me with a brick and make it very obvious. I darkened the upper corners with a vignette mask to help keep the eye in triangle and from wondering off into the corners of the image. And lastly, cleaning up the image. I have another version of this image where I used the rubber stamp tool and Content Aware fill to remove the lines just above the pipe organ. Personally, I like it better than this image as I find the lines a bit distracting. This is a matter of choice.
Happy shooting…..